Why Pesto Turns Brown in Storage – What’s Happening and How to Stop It

You made a fresh, vibrant batch of pesto. The color was electric green. It smelled like a sun-drenched garden in Liguria. You stored it in the fridge, dreaming of pasta and sandwiches and eggs all week long.

In this article, we’ll explore exactly why pesto turns brown in storage—what causes the color shift, what it means for safety and flavor, and how to stop it. You’ll learn about oxidation, enzymatic browning, best storage techniques, and chef-proven tips to keep your pesto fresh, green, and gorgeous for as long as possible.

This is your ultimate deep dive into pesto preservation science—let’s keep that green gold from going gray.

What’s Actually Happening: Why Pesto Turns Brown in Storage?

Pesto browning is a form of enzymatic oxidation, a natural chemical reaction that affects many fresh foods (think apples, avocados, and bananas). In pesto’s case, the primary culprits are:

1. Polyphenol Oxidase (PPO) Enzyme in Basil

Basil leaves are full of polyphenols, natural compounds that react when cut or bruised. When you blend basil into pesto, the PPO enzyme is released, and it immediately begins reacting with oxygen in the air.

This reaction creates melanin-like pigments, which turn the vibrant green hue into a murky, brownish-green color.

2. Exposure to Air (Oxygen = Oxidation)

Oxygen is a key player in browning. The more air your pesto is exposed to—either in the container or when scooping it out—the faster it browns.

3. Heat and Light Accelerate the Process

Even mild heat (like being near the oven or left out during a meal) can speed up oxidation. Light also degrades the chlorophyll in basil, fading the green and dulling the flavor.

4. High Water Content and Poor Oil Coverage

If your pesto doesn’t have enough olive oil or has added water (from rinsed herbs or cheese), it will brown faster. Water doesn’t block oxygen. Oil does.

Is Brown Pesto Still Safe to Eat?

In most cases, yes—brown pesto is still edible, especially if the browning is mild and there’s no mold or foul smell.

However, it may taste slightly bitter or flat, especially if the basil has oxidized heavily.

Here’s how to tell:

Sign	Is It Safe?	What to Do
Slight browning on top	Yes	Scrape off top layer, use rest
Fully brown & dry	Maybe	Taste test; use in cooked dish
Sour/rancid smell	No	Discard
Mold or white fuzz	No	Throw it all out
Fizzy or bubbling	No	Fermentation = toss

How Long Before Pesto Starts to Brown?

How to Stop Pesto from Turning Brown (or at Least Slow It Down)

There’s no perfect solution, but there are several chef-tested methods that dramatically slow browning and preserve that vivid green.

1. Use an Olive Oil Seal

• After transferring pesto to a container, pour a thin layer of olive oil over the surface.
• This blocks oxygen and helps preserve both color and flavor.

2. Add Lemon Juice or Ascorbic Acid

• Acid slows oxidation. Add 1–2 teaspoons of lemon juice during blending.
• You can also add a pinch of ascorbic acid (vitamin C powder) to maintain green color.

3. Blanch the Basil (Optional)

• Blanch basil leaves in boiling water for 5–10 seconds, then shock in ice water.
• This kills the PPO enzyme, slowing oxidation dramatically.
• Downside: Can slightly mute basil’s aroma and soften texture.

4. Store in a Dark, Cold Place

• Keep pesto in the back of the fridge, not near the door.
• Avoid clear containers unless stored in darkness.

5. Always Use a Clean Spoon

• Cross-contamination speeds up spoilage and oxidation.
• Never double-dip.

Best Containers to Preserve Pesto Color

Container Type	Pros	Cons
Glass jar	Airtight, reusable, non-reactive	Heavy, breakable
Silicone tray	Great for freezing in portions	Not airtight once cubes are out
Plastic tub	Lightweight, convenient	Can absorb flavors, stains
Vacuum-sealed bag	Excellent for freezing long-term	Requires vacuum sealer

Pro tip: Always label containers with the pesto type and date.

What Happens When Pesto Browns – Flavor Breakdown

Browning doesn’t just affect appearance. It changes the flavor, too.

• Oxidized basil develops a slightly bitter or grassy aftertaste
• Rancid oils (especially if exposed to heat/light) taste metallic or sour
• Cheese and nuts can take on a stale flavor over time

Use browned pesto in cooked dishes like:

• Pasta sauces
• Egg scrambles
• Roasted veggies
• Grilled sandwiches

But avoid using browned pesto as-is for drizzling or dipping—it just won’t shine.

Can You Fix Browned Pesto?

Pesto Types Most Prone to Browning

Pesto Type	Oxidation Risk	Storage Notes
Basil Genovese	High	Needs oil seal + lemon for best results
Arugula Pesto	Medium	Slight bitterness increases if browned
Red Pepper Pesto	Low	Holds color better than green pestos
Beet Pesto	Low	Vivid pigment resists oxidation
Broccoli or Kale Pesto	Medium	More resilient than basil

Browning Is Natural, But You’re Smarter Than That

Pesto browning might feel like a kitchen tragedy—but it’s totally preventable with the right know-how.

Whether you’re freezing cubes, storing jars, or just trying to keep your leftovers green for the weekend, remember the key rules: limit oxygen, keep it cold, seal it in oil, and don’t wait too long.

Because when pesto is stored properly, it can stay as vibrant, fresh, and full of life as the moment you made it—and every spoonful can still taste like a garden.

Disclosure: Our blog contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. We try our best to keep things fair and balanced, in order to help you make the best choice for you.