Making traditional pesto alla Genovese isn’t just cooking—it’s ceremony
There’s a reason Ligurians hold pesto-making competitions and fiercely guard their family’s mortar and pestle: this isn’t just about food, it’s about doing it right. And while modern gadgets can speed things up, if you really want that unforgettable, vivid, complex pesto—the kind that smells like an Italian summer—you need to follow the steps with intention and care.
In this article, we’ll show you how to make traditional pesto step-by-step, using classic ingredients and simple techniques that bring out bold, fresh flavor. Whether you’re tossing it with pasta or spreading it on crusty bread, knowing the step-by-step means you’ll never settle for store-bought again.
Tools and Ingredients You’ll Need
Tools
- • Mortar and pestle (marble mortar + wooden pestle recommended)
- • OR a food processor or blender (with modified steps)
- • Spatula or wooden spoon
- • Microplane grater
- • Sharp knife or herb shears
- • Clean glass jar or container for storing
Traditional Ingredients
• 2 packed cups fresh Genovese or sweet Italian basil (washed and dried)
• 2 tablespoons raw pine nuts
• 1–2 cloves young garlic
• ½ cup Parmigiano-Reggiano (freshly grated)
• ¼ cup Pecorino Fiore Sardo (freshly grated)
• ½ cup extra virgin olive oil (Liguria-style, if available)
• Pinch of salt
Step-by-Step Instructions Using Mortar and Pestle
This is the traditional method approved by the Consorzio del Pesto Genovese in Genoa. It takes about 20 minutes and yields the most aromatic, textured result.
Step 1 – Crush Garlic and Pine Nuts
Place peeled garlic and pine nuts in the mortar. Use the pestle to:
• Grind in circular motions, not pounding
• Press against the sides of the mortar
• Create a smooth, creamy paste
This becomes your flavor base. You’ll smell the oils release almost instantly.
Step 2 – Add Basil Gradually
Add basil a handful at a time, gently pounding and grinding in circles.
Tips:
• Press basil against the mortar walls to bruise, not shred
• Continue until the basil releases its oils and turns into a green pulp
• This stage should take 7–10 minutes
The basil’s aroma should be intense and sweet. If it smells bitter or cooked, you’re working too fast or hard.
Step 3 – Mix in the Cheeses
Add grated Parmigiano-Reggiano and Pecorino Fiore Sardo. Fold them in by grinding slowly, allowing them to absorb the basil mixture.
The texture should become grainier and slightly stiffer. This is the pesto’s core body.
Step 4 – Slowly Stir in Olive Oil
Pour in extra virgin olive oil in a thin stream, stirring gently with the pestle or a wooden spoon.
You’re not blending—you’re emulsifying. Take your time. The oil will bring everything together into a creamy, luscious green sauce.
Taste and add a pinch of salt only if needed (remember the cheeses are salty).
Step 5 – Serve or Store Properly
Use immediately, or:
• Transfer to a clean glass jar
• Level the surface
• Cover with a thin layer of olive oil to prevent oxidation
• Store in the fridge for up to 5 days
Making Pesto with a Food Processor or Blender
Modern life is busy, and there’s no shame in using a food processor—if you do it right.
Step 1 – Pre-Freeze Blades (Optional, but Smart)
Put your blade attachment in the freezer for 10–15 minutes. This helps reduce heat and oxidation from high-speed blending.
Step 2 – Process Garlic and Pine Nuts First
Pulse garlic and pine nuts together until a coarse paste forms. This mimics mortar grinding and keeps garlic from turning harsh.
Step 3 – Add Basil in Batches
Add your dry basil and pulse in short bursts. Do not over-blend. Scrape down the sides often to avoid uneven chopping.
Step 4 – Add Cheeses
Pulse in Parmigiano and Pecorino until combined but still textured. Avoid making it too smooth.
Step 5 – Slowly Add Olive Oil
With the processor running on low or pulsing, drizzle in the oil slowly. Stop once you reach a spoonable consistency. Stir with a spatula for final emulsification.
Step 6 – Taste and Adjust
Check salt. If needed, add a pinch. Optionally, stir in a tiny splash of lemon juice to preserve color if storing for later.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
| Mistake | Why It’s a Problem | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Over-blending basil | Causes oxidation and bitter taste | Pulse in short bursts, add basil last |
| Using wet basil leaves | Thins the sauce and leads to browning | Wash and air dry completely before use |
| Using pre-grated cheese | Adds anti-caking agents, affects texture | Grate cheese fresh with a microplane |
| Adding oil too quickly | Breaks emulsification, makes oily sauce | Always stir or drizzle oil in slowly |
| Skipping the cheese | Pesto lacks body, depth, and proper salt balance | Don’t skip—even in vegan versions (use alternatives like nutritional yeast) |
Final Tips for Next-Level Pesto
- Serve with trofie, linguine, or gnocchi—not heavy shapes like rigatoni
- Add a spoonful of pasta cooking water when tossing to create a creamy coating
- Avoid heating pesto directly—always add it off heat, or it can turn bitter
- For vegan pesto, use nutritional yeast and extra pine nuts to replicate the cheese depth
Making traditional pesto isn’t hard—it just requires care. And when you do it right, you’ll understand why Ligurians never gave it up, never stopped making it by hand, and never compromised on ingredients.
Whether you’re wielding a mortar or firing up a blender, it’s about balance. About aroma. About honoring the legacy in every leaf of basil.
And once you’ve made it the traditional way—you’ll never look at jarred pesto the same again.
Disclosure: Our blog contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. We try our best to keep things fair and balanced, in order to help you make the best choice for you.
